Skip to content Accessibility info

Augustyniak Insurance

All About Us

Welcome to Augustyniak Insurance Group!  Your Independent Insurance Agency in Jacksonville, Florida

 Our agency is extremely pleased to be recognized by our community and peers as an outstanding Florida Insurance Agency. A few of our recent awards include:

  • Top- Reviewed Insurance Agency in Jacksonville FL on Google
  • Top Three Insurance Agent in Jacksonville, Florida  - 
  • Best of Jacksonville 2015 - Home Insurance Agency Award  

Former New York Jets Running back, Mike Augustyniak founded Augustyniak Insurance Group in 2005.

While our office is located in Jacksonville FL, we have over 3,000 thousand satisfied clients located throughout entire state of Florida – from Sarasota to Orlando to Tallahassee.  Live in a different city in Florida?  No Worries. We help clients throughout the entire State of Florida. 


We are proud to be an Independent Insurance Agency in Jacksonville, FL and a member of Florida Association of Independent Insurance Agents.  We provide our clients choices for their insurance company - utilizing top insurers like AAA, Auto Owners, Nationwide, Progressive and 32 other companies. This means you have options.... saving you time and money.


We provide all types of  to our clients including Car, Homeowners, Motorcycle, Boat, Renters and Umbrella Insurance. We can also assist you in protecting you &  your loved ones with . Some of our Commercial insurance coverages include Small Business Insurance, Workers Compensation, Commercial Auto & General Liability.


Let us help you find the right coverage for you and lower your insurance costs!   At Augustyniak Insurance Group, each one of our clients are given a dedicated team of experts that work together to proficiently address all your concerns.  


Mike & Susan Augustyniak – Agency Owners

"Email me" <mikea [at] weshopinsurance [dot] com>


Get vCard

"Email me" <susang [at] weshopinsurance [dot] com>


Get vCard

Susan Augustyniak

HGTV addict, Westie Lover, and Insurance Agency Owner

Susan is a native Floridian who never dreamed of a career in insurance. She graduated with honors from the University of Florida with plans on going to law school. But Nationwide Insurance, one of Gainesville’s largest employers, hired her out of college. She spent the next 10 years moving quickly up through the Nationwide ranks working as a commercial underwriter, claims adjuster, large loss adjuster, and district sales manager, before she left corporate insurance. In 2008, she joined her now husband, Mike Augustyniak, to work in the agency side of insurance. Together they have built a very successful award winning agency in Jacksonville, FL. She loves her career choice of insurance and has never looked back!  She enjoys good conversation about on places to travel to, ways to save money, or how to use technology to make life and business better. When she is not at the office, Susan loves to watch HGTV,  spoil her 2 Westies (Max and Maggie),  and travel with her husband Mike.

Mike Augustyniak

Former NFL Running back, College Football Fan, & Insurance Agency Owner

Mike Augustyniak is the middle of 9 children, and grew up in rural Indiana. He fell in love with football during middle school. Football shaped his strong work ethic, competitive spirit, and team focus during high school. He walked on-- to what he calls “a tackling dummy position” – with Purdue University Football. But his work ethic payed off, and quickly earned a scholarship and became the team’s starting Running back. After the Boilermakers, the NFL did not draft him. So he walked-on to the NY Jets team tryouts. Again, he beat the odds, and earned the starting running back position with the Jets. Mike was fortunate to play for 4 seasons before sustaining a career ending knee injury. After the NFL, Mike changed careers to insurance. For 15 years, he was a top-tier award-winning Agency Sales Manager for Allstate Insurance and Nationwide Insurance in Florida. Outside of work, Mike loves watching College Football, playing Golf, and playing with the Westies - Max and Maggie.