Skip to content Accessibility info

Augustyniak Insurance

All About Us

Award-Winning Service & Personalized Insurance Coverage



Meet Augustyniak Insurance – Jacksonville’s Trusted Insurance Agents

At Augustyniak Insurance Group, we help people feel confident in their insurance choices. As a top-rated independent insurance agency in Jacksonville, FL — with over 2,000 five-star Google reviews — we work to match you with the right coverage at the best value, backed by a team that genuinely cares.

Our Client Commitment

We guide every client toward a plan that includes:

  • The Right Coverage: Smart protection, tailored to your life.
  • The Best Price: We compare 30+ insurers to find your best value.
  • World-Class Service: Fast answers. Claims support. Real people.

What Sets Us Apart

  • Independent Choice: Access to over 32 top carriers, like AAA, Auto-Owners, Nationwide, and Progressive.
  • Proven Expertise: Founded in 2005 by former NY Jets running back Mike Augustyniak. Recognized for:
    • 2,600+ Google reviews
    • Top 3 Agents in Jacksonville – ThreeBestRated (2018–2024)
    • Best of Jacksonville – Insurance Agency Award (2015–2024)
  • Statewide Reach: Over 5,000 clients served across Florida—from Sarasota to Tallahassee.
  • Complete Coverage: Personal: Auto, Home, Umbrella, Life. Business: Liability, Workers’ Comp, and more.
  • Team-Based Support: You’ll work with a responsive, knowledgeable team that puts you first.

Finding the Perfect Fit

Insurance can be confusing—but it doesn’t have to be. We take time to explain your options and help you protect what matters most. The process is simple, transparent, and focused on your peace of mind.

Contact Us Today

Whether you're in Jacksonville or anywhere in Florida, Augustyniak Insurance Group is ready to help. Call us at (904) 268-3106, visit us at 12058 San Jose Blvd, Suite 304, Jacksonville, FL 32223, or request your free quote online.

Susan Augustyniak

Susan Augustyniak


"Email me" <susang [at] weshopinsurance [dot] com>

904-268-3106

Get vCard

Michael Augustyniak

Michael Augustyniak


"Email me" <mikea [at] weshopinsurance [dot] com>

904-268-3106

Get vCard

Mike & Susan Augustyniak – Agency Owners


Susan Augustyniak

HGTV addict, Westie Lover, and Insurance Agency Owner

Susan is a native Floridian who never dreamed of an insurance career. She graduated with honors from the University of Florida with plans on going to law school. But Nationwide Insurance, one of Gainesville’s largest employers, hired her out of college. She spent the next 10 years moving quickly up through the Nationwide ranks working as a commercial underwriter, claims adjuster, large loss adjuster, and district sales manager before she left corporate insurance. In 2008, she joined her now husband, Mike Augustyniak, to work in the agency side of insurance. Together they have built a very successful award-winning agency in Jacksonville, FL. She loves her career choice of insurance and has never looked back!  She enjoys good conversations about places to travel to, ways to save money, or how to use technology to make life and business better. When she is not at the office, Susan loves to watch HGTV,  spoil her 2 Westies (Max and Mollie),  and travel with her husband Mike.


Mike Augustyniak

Former NY Jets NFL Running back, College Football Fan, & Insurance Agency Owner

Mike Augustyniak is the middle of 9 children and grew up in rural Indiana. He fell in love with football during middle school. Football shaped his strong work ethic, competitive spirit, and team focus during high school. He walked on-- to what he calls “a tackling dummy position” – with Purdue University Football. But his work ethic paid off, and quickly earned a scholarship and became the team’s starting Running back. After the Boilermakers, the NFL did not draft him. So he walked on to the NY Jets team tryouts. Again, he beat the odds and earned the starting running back position with the Jets. Mike was fortunate to play for 4 seasons before sustaining a career-ending knee injury. After the NFL, Mike changed careers to insurance. For 15 years, he was a top-tier award-winning Agency Sales Manager for Allstate Insurance and Nationwide Insurance in Florida. Outside of work, Mike loves watching College Football, playing Golf, and playing with the Westies - Max and Mollie.