- 2,250+Five-Star Reviews
- 80+Insurance Companies
- 20+Years in Florida
- 4.9★Google Rating
We are Augustyniak Insurance Group, an independent agency in Jacksonville. We review hundreds of renewals every month and help homeowners figure out their next move. Want us to compare your renewal now? Call (904) 268-3106. Want to understand first? Keep reading.
Your Renewal Went Up. Now What?
You open the envelope. Your homeowners' insurance went from $3,200 to $4,100. No claims. No explanation. No phone call or email from your agent. Just a bigger number and a due date.
This happens to thousands of Jacksonville homeowners every year. The question is not whether your rate will go up. In Florida, it probably will at some point. The question is what your agent does about it.
What Should You Do After a Home Insurance Rate Increase in Jacksonville?
- Review your renewal notice.
Look at what changed: premium, deductibles, coverage limits. - Ask your agent what caused the increase.
Statewide rate filing? Roof age threshold? Rebuild cost adjustment? - Ask them to review your policy. Ask them how companies many they shopped
If the answer is one, you do not have the full picture. - Check for missing discounts.
Wind mitigation credits, claims-free discounts, water shut off devices, or updated inspections. - Get a comparison from an independent agent.
An independent agent can show you what 10 to 80+ companies would charge for the same coverage. It takes about 5 minutes to start.
4 Things Your Agent Should Do When Your Rate Increases
1. Contact you before your renewal date
A proactive agent reviews your renewal 30 to 60 days before it hits or during your annual review. They see the increase coming and reach out to you with options before you get the bill.
2. Explain why the increase happened
Rate increases have reasons. Maybe your company filed a statewide increase. Maybe your roof aged past a pricing threshold. Maybe rebuild costs in your area went up. A good agent tells you exactly what caused it and whether it is something you can address.
For the bigger picture on why Florida rates are high: Why Jacksonville Insurance Rates Are So High in 2026.
3. Show you what other companies are charging
This is the most important step. An independent agent should review your renewal and compare it against other options. If another company offers better pricing for the same coverage, you should know about it.
If your current company is still the best fit, a good agent will tell you that too and explain why. Either way, you deserve to see the comparison.
4. Look for savings you might be missing
Sometimes the best move is not switching companies. Sometimes it is adjusting your deductible, updating your wind mitigation report, or verifying that your dwelling coverage matches your actual rebuild cost. A good agent explores all of these before recommending a change.
Reviews your options 30 to 60 days early
Tells you exactly what drove the increase
Shows you side-by-side options
Wind mitigation, claims-free credits, and deductible adjustments
Explains nothing and expects you to pay the higher amount
No proactive outreach, no annual review
"I looked into it" without specifics, is not enough
5 Signs It Is Time to Find a New Insurance Agency
- You only hear from your agent when it is time to pay.
No proactive renewal review, no annual coverage check-in. Silence between renewals is a red flag. - They have not offered to review your policy with you
If they didn't reach out to review your policy with you or provide options to consider - They represent only one insurance company.
A captive agent cannot show you better options because they do not have any. An independent agent represents many. - They do not understand Florida-specific options.
Wind mitigation credits, private flood alternatives, hurricane deductible trade-offs. These are standard knowledge for a Florida agent, not extras. - Your calls go unanswered.
If you cannot reach your agent within one to two business days, what will happen during a claim?
For the full checklist on evaluating agencies: How to Choose the Best Insurance Agency in Jacksonville, FL.
Your Renewal Went Up. Let Us See What Else Is Out There.
Bring us your declarations page. We compare 80+ companies and most quotes come back the same day. Takes about 5 minutes to get started.
Call (904) 268-3106 Compare Your Rate Across 80+ Companies Augustyniak Insurance Group · 80+ companies · 2,250+ reviewsHow to Prepare Before Talking to a New Agent
Have your current declarations page ready. It is the summary page of your policy that shows your coverage limits, deductibles, premium, and which company insures you. A new agent can use this to quote you accurately without starting from scratch.
If you have a wind mitigation report or 4-point inspection, bring those too. They can unlock significant discounts with a new company that your current agent may not be applying.
You do not have to cancel anything to get a comparison. A good agent will quote you, show you the options, and let you decide. No pressure, no obligation.
For the step-by-step switching guide: 5 Questions to Ask Before Switching Insurance Agencies in Florida.
Frequently Asked Questions
Should I switch insurance companies every year in Florida?
Not necessarily. But you should expect your agent to review your renewal every year. A review is a service check-in, not a sales appointment. Your agent looks at what changed, whether your current company is still competitive, and whether any adjustments make sense.
Sometimes the best recommendation is to stay put. The point is that someone is looking out for you.
Can my insurance company raise my rate without telling me?
They must send you a renewal notice. But the notice often arrives with only 30 to 45 days before your renewal date. That is why a proactive agent reviews it before the notice even arrives.
Will switching insurance agents affect my coverage?
No. Your coverage is determined by the policy, not the agent. A new agent can place you with the same company through an agent of record change, or find you a better option with a different company. There is no coverage gap or penalty for switching agencies.
What is an agent of record change?
An agent of record (AOR) change transfers your existing policy from one agency to another without changing your company, coverage, or premium. It is useful when you want better service but are happy with your current insurance company.
How long does it take to switch agencies?
If you are doing an agent of record change, it can be done in a few days. If you are switching to a new company, most quotes come back within one to two business days. Your new agent handles the paperwork and coordinates the transition so there is no lapse in coverage.
Compare Your Homeowners Insurance Now
Fill out the form below and our team will compare your renewal against 80+ companies. Most quotes come back the same day or next business day.
Prefer to Talk to Someone?
Our team is here Monday through Friday, 8:30 AM to 5:00 PM. No phone trees. Real people who understand Florida insurance.
Call (904) 268-3106 Augustyniak Insurance Group · 12058 San Jose Blvd, Jacksonville FL
Susan Augustyniak, CIC
Vice President, Augustyniak Insurance Group
Certified Insurance Counselor with 25+ years in the industry. Before joining Augustyniak Insurance Group in 2008, Susan spent nine years at Nationwide Insurance as a commercial underwriter, large loss property claims adjuster, and sales manager. She holds a Florida 2-20 General Lines Agent license and helps Jacksonville homeowners navigate coverage decisions across Duval, St. Johns, Clay, and Nassau counties. Published May 2026.